Exploring the Interplay Between Sleep, Body Clock, and Mental Health
The review, published today [19 February] in Proceedings of the National Academy (PNAS), suggests gaining a better understanding of the relationship between sleep, circadian rhythms and mental health could unlock new holistic treatments to alleviate mental health problems.
“Sleep-circadian disturbances are the rule, rather than the exception, across every category of psychiatric disorders,” said Dr Sarah L. Chellappa from the University of Southampton, senior author of the review. “Sleep disturbances, such as insomnia, are well understood in the development and maintenance of psychiatric disorders, but our understanding of circadian disturbances lags behind.
“It is important to understand how these factors interact so we can develop and apply sleep-circadian interventions that benefit the sleep and mental health symptoms of patients.”
An international team of researchers from the Universities of Southampton, Bristol, King’s College London, Stanford University, and other institutions explored recent evidence on sleep and circadian factors, focusing on adolescents and young adults with psychiatric disorders. This is a time when people are most at risk of developing mental health disorders and when disruption to sleep and circadian rhythms are likely to occur.
Insomnia is more common in people with mental health disorders than in the general population – during remission, acute episodes and especially in early psychosis, where difficulty falling and staying asleep affects over half of individuals. Around a quarter to a third of people with mood disorders have both insomnia and hypersomnia, where patients find it hard to sleep at night, but are sleepier in the daytime. Similar proportions of people with psychosis experience this combination of sleep disorders.
Meanwhile, the few studies looking at circadian rhythm sleep-wake disorders (CRSWD) suggest that 32% of patients with bipolar disorder go to sleep and wake later than usual (a condition called Delayed Sleep-Wake Phase Disorder). Body clock processes (such as endogenous cortisol rhythms) have been reported to run seven hours ahead during manic episodes and four to five hours behind during the depressive phase. Timing is normalised upon successful treatment.
The researchers examined the possible mechanisms behind sleep-circadian disturbances in psychiatric disorders. During adolescence, physiological changes in how we sleep combine with behavioural changes, such as staying up later, getting less sleep on school nights and sleeping in on weekends.
Dr Nicholas Meyer, from King’s College London, who co-led the review, said: “This variability in the duration and timing of sleep can lead to a misalignment between our body clock and our sleep-wake rhythms can increase the risk of sleep disturbances and adverse mental health outcomes.”
Matt Jones, Professor in Neuroscience in the School of Physiology, Pharmacology & Neuroscience at the University of Bristol, added: “Many current treatments for psychiatric disorders are based on one-size-fits-all, trial-and-error approaches. Understanding the sleep and circadian patterns of individuals living with these disorders offers exciting opportunities for early intervention and the precisely tailored therapies people deserve. New, wearable devices able to accurately measure these sleep and circadian patterns across long timescales should really help bring this precision to psychiatry.”
Researchers also looked at the role of genes, exposure to light, neuroplasticity and other possible factors. Those with a genetic predisposition towards a reduced change in activity levels between rest and wake phases are more likely to experience depression, mood instability, and neuroticism. Population-level surveys show self-reported time outdoors was associated with a lower probability of mood disorder. Sleep is thought to play a key role in how the brain forms new neural connections and processes emotional memories.
Dr Renske Lok, from Stanford University, who co-led the review, said: “Targeting sleep and circadian risk factors presents the opportunity to develop new preventative measures and therapies. Some of these are population-level considerations, such as the timing of school and work days, or changes in the built environment to optimise light exposure. Others are personalised interventions tailored to individual circadian parameters.”
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I) has been shown to reduce anxiety and depressive symptoms, as well as trauma symptoms in people experiencing PTSD.
In unipolar and bipolar depression, light therapy (delivered on rising in the morning) was effective compared with a placebo. Using it in combination with medication was also more effective than using medication alone. Other findings suggest light is effective in treating perinatal depression.
The timing of medication, meals and exercise could also impact circadian phases. Taking melatonin in the evening can help people with Delayed Sleep-Wake Phase Disorder to shift their body clock forward towards a more conventional sleep pattern and may have beneficial effects in comorbid psychiatric disorders. Nightshift work can adversely affect mental health but eating in the daytime rather than during the night could help, with research showing daytime eating prevents mood impairment.
The review also points to innovative multicomponent interventions, such as Transdiagnostic Intervention for Sleep and Circadian dysfunction (Trans-C). This combines modules that address different aspects of sleep and circadian rhythms into a sleep health framework that applies to a range of mental health disorders.
Dr Chellappa said: “Collectively, research into mental health is poised to take advantage of extraordinary advances in sleep and circadian science and translate these into improved understanding and treatment of psychiatric disorders.”
The research was funded by the Alexander Von Humboldt Foundation.