University of Sydney: During general anaesthesia, 1 in 10 people may be ‘conscious’ following intubation

An international study has found around 1 in 10 participants under planned general anaesthesia were able to respond to commands. Importantly, no subjects remembered the commands after surgery. Researchers say the study sheds light on a medical phenomenon known as connected consciousness.

‘Connected consciousness’ occurs when people under general anaesthetic are able to respond to outside stimuli such as pain but may not be able to recall the event afterwards.

Previous studies showed it occurred in five percent of general anaesthetics, but researchers are concerned it is actually happening more frequently in young people and is linked to biological sex.

An international investigation of ‘connected consciousness’ on 338 patients aged from 18 to 40 under general anaesthesia, found 1 in 10 patients responded to commands after intubation but before surgery started. Nearly half of those who responded to commands also responded to confirm they had pain.

One surprising finding was the risk of being responsive under general anaesthetic after intubation was three times higher in females.

Fortunately, no one remembered the commands, though one person (0.3 percent of participants) reported was able to clearly recall the experience of surgery after the procedure ended.

There are different approaches to inducing anaesthesia to allow intubation. Sometimes patients are given a single dose of an anaesthetic to help them lose consciousness and an additional drug to stop movement.

The study has found that maintaining a continued level of anaesthesia before intubation decreased the risk of ‘connected consciousness’ in patients.

The data from the study has given us a crucial starting point in improving our understanding of ‘connected consciousness.’
Dr Robert Sanders
Provision of continuous anaesthesia during that time is standard practice in Australia.

The findings, published in the British Journal of Anaesthesia, is the largest international cohort study of its kind, involving 338 participants and 10 hospitals across Australia, Belgium, Germany, Israel, New Zealand, and the United States of America.

“The data from the study has given us a crucial starting point in improving our understanding of ‘connected consciousness’. Patients expect to be unconscious under anaesthesia, and not be in pain, and this demonstrates why research into anaesthesia is so important,” said senior author Professor Robert Sanders.

Professor Sanders is an anaesthetist from the University of Sydney and Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. None of the patients recruited were from Royal Prince Alfred Hospital.

“The goal is not to discourage people from surgeries under general anaesthetic – it is very important to note that patients did not remember responding to the commands,” said Professor Sanders.

“It was also reassuring to see that if anaesthetic drugs are administered continuously in the time period between induction of anaesthesia and intubation, the risk of connected consciousness was greatly reduced.

“This research also highlights the need to better understand how different people respond to the anaesthesia medication. There is an urgent need for further research on the biological differences, particularly sex, that may influence sensitivity to anaesthetic medication.”

Key findings
The study involved patients from 18 to 40 years old undergoing general anaesthetic and intubation.

While under general anaesthetic, researchers investigated whether patients were experiencing ‘connected consciousness’ by asking them a series of questions and testing whether the patient could respond to spoken commands such as ‘squeeze my hand’ and ‘squeeze my hand twice if you are experiencing pain’.

11 percent of participants responded to commands while under general anaesthetic.
Females were three times more likely to respond than males (odds ratio of 2.7)
half of the 11 percent of participants that responded to commands also indicated they were in pain.
Lead author Assistant Professor Richard Lennertz from the Department of Anaesthesiology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, USA said:

“It is important to emphasize the overall safety of anaesthesia. Patients had no memory of these experiences after surgery. This study highlights an ongoing commitment to patient safety in anaesthesiology and an opportunity for further improvement in patient care.”

Co-author, Dr Amy Gaskell from Waikato Hospital, New Zealand commented:

“In this study, we have confirmed that the state of connected consciousness occurs not infrequently following intubation in younger patients. We identified quite a variation in practice around the time of intubation which might explain why some of the responses were possible. The higher incidence in females is also very interesting and we look forward to exploring the reasons behind this.”